During the COVID-19 outbreak, our menu may be limited.

Please visit our Facebook page for current offerings.


Soup of the Day | 3 cup, 5 bowl

Harvest Board | 8 small, 14 large

Specialty Meats and Cheeses

Joyce’s Famous Pierogi |4 each

Choice of Farmer’s Cheese, Sauerkraut, Potato Cheddar

Loaded Tater Tots | 8

Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Green Onion, Sour Cream

Coconut Shrimp | 8

Six Crispy Shrimp, Sweet Thai Chili Sauce


Pretzel Sticks | 7

Three Soft Pretzels, Mustard, Cheese Sauce

Fried Homemade Noodles | 5

Topped with Mozzarella



The Wedge | 10

Iceberg, Tomato, Cucumber, Bacon, Egg, Cheddar, Croutons

BLT Salad | 9

Bacon, Romaine, Tomato, Croutons, Parmesan Crisps


Village Green | 9

Fresh Spinach Salad with Seasonal Toppings


House Salad | 5

Lettuce Blend, Tomato, Cucumber, Onion


Sandwiches & Such

Served with French Fries | Substitute Sweet Potato Fries for $3


Western New Yorker | 13

Grilled Pastrami, Swiss, Red Onion, Horseradish Aioli


Beef on Weck | 11

Tender, Fresh-Sliced Roast Beef, Kimmelweck


Star Burger | 12

Half-Pound Fresh Ground Beef, Cheese,

Lettuce, Tomato, Onion


Bleu Bison Burger | 15

Half-Pound Organic Bison, Crumbly Bleu Cheese,

Lettuce, Tomato, Onion 


Kielbasa & Kraut | 9

Smoked Wardynski’s Sausage, Sauerkraut,

Rustic Hoagie Roll


Chicken Caprese | 10

Fresh Mozzarella, Spinach, Tomato, Pesto Mayo


Pulled Pork on a Pretzel Roll | 10
Tennessee Style: Topped with Coleslaw

OR Polska Style: Topped with Sweet & Sour Cabbage

Fingers & Fries | 10

Crispy Chicken Tenders, Made Fresh In-house


Nana’s Breakfast | 8

Sausage and Homemade Noodles Scrambled with Eggs,

Baby Potato Pancakes 


The Classic | Half 7, Whole 12

Marinara, Mozzarella, Pepperoni |


The Cowboy | Half 8, Whole 14

Steak or Chicken, Spinach, Crumbly Bleu, Mozzarella


The Italiano | Half 7, Whole 12

Chicken, Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil


The Farmer | Half 6, Whole 11

Bell Pepper, Onion, Tomato, Mushroom, Mozzarella



Only available after 4pm | Add soup or salad for $2


Butcher’s Cut Steak | 28

12-oz Strip Steak, Fresh Vegetable, Potato


Pan-Seared Salmon | 21

Lemon Butter Sauce, Fresh Vegetable, Potato


Premium Pork Chop | 18

Grilled Pork Chop, Kapusta, Grilled Apple Slices,

Fresh Vegetable, Potato


Polska Best | 17

Golumbki, Pierogi, Kapusta, Smoked Sausage


Chicken Penne | 15

Pan-Seared Chicken, Garden Vegetables,

Artichokes, Pesto or Cream Sauce


Shepherd’s Pie | 14

Beef, Vegetables, Gravy, Mashed Potatoes, Cheddar




Served with French Fries and 2 of the following:

Macaroni Salad, German Potato Salad,

American Potato Salad, Coleslaw


Beer Battered Haddock | 13


Cajun Broiled Haddock | 14


Lemon Pepper Broiled Haddock | 14


Bruschetta Broiled Haddock | 15

Homemade Bruschetta Topping, Mozzarella


Breaded Shrimp Dinner | 14



Wednesday - Friday: Limited pickup windows - see Facebook for details

Saturday - Tuesday: Closed

7340 Seneca Street | Elma, NY 14059

E | TheNorthStarTavern@gmail.com

T |  (716) 805-7117