Hello, North Star friends & family! 

As the pandemic continues, and restrictions are ever-changing we will continue to work hard to keep you informed about our plans. 


While our hearts always want to stay open, we know that for the long-term health of the North Star, we may need to change the way we do business at times.

Please stay tuned to our website and Facebook page for updates.


Thank you all so much for your support throughout the pandemic.

We are so grateful for your kindness and patronage during this difficult time. 

Stay safe and healthy,

Tim & Joyce Chrostowski

If you have questions or want to place an order, please call us at (716) 805-7117.

Join us during Lent for

our fantastic fish fry!

Come by every Friday for fresh,

never frozen haddock and salads made from scratch.

You won't find a better fish fry in Western New York!

Thank you for voting for the

North Star as the best entree at the

2020 Taste of East Aurora Restaurant Week and favorite dessert at the 2017 Taste of East Aurora!

Did you see us in the News?

Click below to read the articles!

Current Hours

Thurs, Nov 19, open 12-8, in-house dining (reservations encouraged) and takeout, full menu available.

Fri, Nov 20, open 12-8, takeout only. fish fry & full menu available (Pre-order strongly encouraged)

Sat, Nov 21 through Thurs. Nov 26 (Thanksgiving Day) Closed

Fri, Nov 27, open 12-8, takeout only, fish fry & limited menu available (Pre-order strongly encouraged)

Get in Touch

7340 Seneca Street | Elma, NY 14059

E | TheNorthStarTavern@gmail.com

T |  (716) 805-7117